When you find yourself repeatedly drawn to people who can’t fully love you back, it’s not because you’re broken. Often, it’s because there’s a deeper story within you that needs to be heard and healed – a story that lives in your shadow self, those parts of you that you’ve learned to hide, deny, or push away. Let’s explore why your heart keeps reaching for those emotionally unavailable partners who keep their own hearts just out of reach.

Recreating Familiar Patterns from Your Past

Think back to your earliest experiences of love. Perhaps you had a parent who was physically present but emotionally distant. Maybe they would light up your world with attention one day, then retreat into their shell the next. When this happens in our formative years, we learn to associate love with uncertainty and distance.

Now, when you meet someone who feels slightly out of reach, it triggers something deep within you – a dance you’ve danced before, a language your heart speaks fluently, even though it may hurt. Although it feels familiar, it doesn’t always mean it is good for you.

Self-awareness is the key to breaking this toxic cycle. Connect with your younger self through gentle self-reflection. When you feel drawn to someone emotionally distant, pause and ask: “Does this feeling remind me of my past?” Write a letter to your younger self, acknowledging their pain and promising to choose differently now.

In detail, write down how you want to be treated now as an adult, then honor your need to feel like a priority. Practice sitting with the discomfort of unfamiliar, consistent love rather than running toward the familiar pain of unavailability.

The Chase Feels Like Proof of Your Worth

Remember that time you finally got a small sign of affection from someone who usually kept their distance? How your heart soared, how special it felt? It’s intoxicating because, for a moment, you felt truly chosen. The challenge of winning someone’s love can feel like a chance to prove your value, to show that you’re “good enough.” But darling, you were already enough, long before anyone else’s validation.

It’s time that you understand your worth and learn how to be the chooser rather than chasing love. Choose a partner that can actually meet your needs. Create a “Worth Journal” where you document your amazing qualities outside of your achievements and moments of self-pride that have nothing to do with relationships.

For example, how empathetic you are as a friend or how you make people feel seen and heard. When you feel the urge to chase someone’s validation, open this journal instead. Practice saying “no” to breadcrumbs of affection and “yes” to consistent care – both from yourself and others.

You’re Protecting Yourself from Real Vulnerability

When you pursue someone who can’t fully commit, there’s a hidden safety in it. Deep down, you might be thinking, “If they never fully let me in, they can never fully reject the real me.” It’s like keeping one foot out the door of your own heart. I know it feels safer this way, but this safety comes at the cost of the deep, soul-nourishing connection you truly deserve.

You deserve more than half-hearted love. You only learned how to love this way to protect yourself. Here’s the good news: you can slowly learn how to be vulnerable and let REAL love in. Start small – share one authentic feeling each day with a trusted friend. When you notice yourself pulling back, gently lean in instead.

Practice emotional exposure in safe spaces: join a support group; I believe I can help you open up in a safe space or connect with friends who model healthy vulnerability. Remember, true strength lies in being seen, not in hiding.

Ready to meet someone at your level and effort? I made this video for you. (Article continued below)

The Intensity of Intermittent Connection Feels Like Passion

Those rare moments when they do show up fully – they feel magical, don’t they? The contrast between their distance and sudden presence creates a rush of emotion that can feel like deep love. It’s like dying of thirst in a desert – even a few drops of water feel like everything. But love shouldn’t feel like rationing water in a desert; it should feel like living beside a flowing river.

Realize that hot and cold isn’t love; this kind of feeling can create an addiction to love, but it’s chemicals and hormones temporarily pumping through your body. It isn’t real love. You deserve more than just a momentary connection. Create a “Love Reality Check” list that compares healthy vs. intermittent connection.

When you feel swept away by intensity, consult this list. Practice finding joy in steady, reliable connections – appreciate the friend who always texts back, the family member who shows up consistently. Learn to trust that calm waters run deep.

You’re Trying to Heal Old Wounds Through New People

Every time you try to win over someone who’s emotionally unavailable, part of you might be trying to rewrite an old story. Perhaps you’re unconsciously thinking, “If I can make this person love me fully, it will heal all the times I wasn’t loved enough before.” This is such a human thing to do, and it comes from a place of deep hope. But healing comes from acknowledging these wounds and learning to tend to them yourself, not from trying to prove your lovability to someone who isn’t ready to love.

Unconditional love starts with self-love. Develop a self-parenting practice. Each morning, ask yourself: “What does my inner child need today?” Then provide it – whether it’s comfort, play, rest, or celebration. When old wounds surface, place a hand on your heart and say: “I’m here now, and I can take care of you.” Break the cycle of seeking healing from others by becoming your own consistent source of love.

Remember, your attraction to emotionally unavailable people isn’t a flaw in your character – it’s a sign that some part of you is asking to be heard and healed. The path forward isn’t about judging yourself for these patterns, but about understanding them with gentleness and choosing to write a new story for yourself, one where love doesn’t have to be earned through endless proving or chasing.

You deserve someone who meets your love with equal enthusiasm, who makes you feel secure rather than anxious, who shows up consistently rather than sporadically. The first step isn’t finding that person – it’s believing, truly believing, that this kind of love is possible for you.

Building a New Story

Write down your old love story – all the patterns, beliefs, and wounds. Then, write your new love story – how you want to feel, be treated, and show up in relationships. Read both regularly, celebrating when you choose differently and showing yourself compassion when old patterns emerge. Remember, you’re not just breaking patterns – you’re building new ones.

Remember, these patterns didn’t form overnight, and they won’t transform overnight either. Every small step toward secure love is progress. Every time you choose differently, you’re rewriting your love story. You’re not just healing – you’re evolving into someone who knows they deserve consistent, secure love.

The journey to healing these patterns isn’t linear. There will be days when old habits feel overwhelming, and that’s okay. What matters is your commitment to showing up for yourself, again and again, choosing love that feels like coming home rather than chasing what feels like running away.

Ready for Transformation?

If these patterns resonate with you and you’re ready to create lasting change, I invite you to take the next step. Book a Free Relationship Readiness Review with me here, where we’ll dive deeper into your specific patterns and create a personalized roadmap to secure, conscious dating. Together, we’ll transform these wounds into wisdom and build the foundation for the love you truly deserve.

The post Attracted to Emotionally Unavailable People? The Psychology Behind Why (& How to Stop) appeared first on Amie Leadingham - Amie the Dating Coach | Master Certified Relationship Coach | Online Dating Expert | Author .